With the Federal Reserve expected to cut interest rates in September 2025, many six-figure earners ($100K-$200K household income) are wondering if it’s time to buy a home or stick with renting. For single households or sole earners in this range, the decision is even more critical, as affordability hinges on take-home pay after taxes and expenses. Mortgage rates are already pricing in the cut, hovering at 6.32% for a 30-year fixed as of September 9, 2025, down from summer highs. But is buying smart now, or is renting the better play? At SixFigureEdge, we’ll break down the pros and cons, affordability for your income bracket, and what the 2025 housing market says.
The 2025 Housing Market Snapshot
The Fed’s anticipated 25 basis point cut (89% probability per CME FedWatch) could push mortgage rates toward 6% by year-end, making borrowing cheaper. However, home prices remain elevated, with median sales at $412,300 (up 2.5% year-over-year). Inventory is improving—up 15% from 2024—but competition is fierce in desirable areas. For $100K-$200K earners, this means qualifying for loans up to $300K-$600K, but closing costs and maintenance add 2-5% annually.
Renting, meanwhile, costs 38% less than owning on average, with median rent at $1,983/month (up 3% year-over-year). In high-demand markets, renters need $100K+ to afford average rents comfortably, a figure that’s doubled since 2020. For a single $100K-$200K earner, the choice boils down to short-term flexibility vs. long-term equity.
Debt-to-Income Ratio (DTI) and Housing Guidelines
When deciding between buying and renting, debt-to-income ratio (DTI) is a key factor. DTI measures your monthly debt payments as a percentage of your gross income, and lenders use it to assess affordability. The standard guideline is the 28/36 rule: no more than 28% of your income on housing (mortgage or rent plus utilities, insurance), and 36% on all debts (housing plus credit cards, loans, etc.).
For $100K-$200K earners, a 28% housing DTI means $2,333-$4,667/month max on housing. But in 2025, many exceed this—average U.S. housing spend is 32-40% of income for this bracket, up from 25-30% a decade ago, due to rising rents and home prices (outpacing wage growth by 15%). Sole earners face tighter limits, as lenders cap total DTI at 45% for most loans. If your DTI hits 40%, buying could be challenging without a large down payment. In today’s world, a higher percentage of people’s incomes are going toward housing costs than ever before, with some cities pushing 50%+ for median earners, forcing trade-offs like smaller living spaces or delayed savings.
Buying a Home in 2025: Pros and Cons for $100K-$200K Earners
Pros:
- Equity Building: With rates potentially dropping to 6%, a $400K home (affordable on $150K income) builds $50K-$100K equity over 5 years at 3% appreciation. For single earners, this is a hedge against rent hikes (average 3-5% annually).
- Tax Benefits: Mortgage interest deduction saves $2,000-$4,000/year at 24% bracket, plus property tax write-offs. In 2025, with inflation at 2.3%, owning locks in costs.
- Stability: Fixed payments (e.g., $2,200/month on $400K loan at 6.32%) protect against rent increases, ideal for sole earners planning long-term.
Cons:
- Upfront Costs: Down payment (5-20%, $20K-$80K) and closing fees (2-5%, $8K-$20K) strain savings. For $150K earners, this could mean depleting emergency funds. Many, especially first-time buyers, put less than 20% down (average 6-12% for first-timers), triggering private mortgage insurance (PMI) at 0.5-1.5% of the loan ($1,500-$4,500/year on $300K loan), adding $125-$375/month until 20% equity is reached.
- Ongoing Expenses: Maintenance (1-2% of home value/year, $4K-$8K) and property taxes (1-2%, $4K-$8K) add up, especially for single households without dual income.
- Market Risk: Prices may dip 5-10% if rates fall further (per some forecasts), leaving buyers underwater short-term.
For a $150K single earner, buying a $350K home (10% down, with PMI) at 6.32% means $2,000/month payments plus $200 PMI, totaling $26,400/year—comparable to renting but with equity gain.
Renting in 2025: Pros and Cons for $100K-$200K Earners
Pros:
- Lower Barrier: No down payment or closing costs—$1,983 median rent is affordable on $150K (20% of take-home), leaving more for investments or emergencies.
- Flexibility: Ideal for single earners with job mobility—average lease 12 months, no resale hassle. In volatile 2025, renting avoids market crashes.
- Predictable Costs: Utilities and repairs are landlord responsibilities, saving $3K-$5K/year vs. owning.
Cons:
- No Equity: Rent hikes (3-5%) erode wealth—$150K earners could pay $150K+ in rent over 5 years without building assets.
- Limited Control: Landlord decisions (e.g., rent increases) affect stability, and in competitive markets, securing a lease costs time and fees.
- Long-Term Cost: Renting forever means missing $200K+ equity over 10 years—less ideal for $200K earners aiming for retirement.
For a $150K single earner, renting at $2,000/month totals $24,000/year—cheaper short-term but no asset growth.
Affordability for $100K-$200K Single Households
On $150K, take-home is ~$110K after federal taxes (single filer). A 28% DTI allows $3,500/month housing. At 6.32%, this buys a $450K home (10% down $45K, with $250/month PMI)—feasible in affordable markets but tough in high-cost ones. On $100K, take-home ~$75K supports $2,100/month, affording a $300K home with PMI.
The Fed cut could lower rates to 6%, saving $100/month on a $400K loan. But inventory shortages (up 15% but still low) keep prices high. Renting suits if mobility is key; buying if staying 5+ years.
When Buying Wins vs. Renting
- Buy if: You plan to stay 5-7 years, have 10-20% down ($45K+), and live in affordable areas (e.g., Houston, $150K buys more). Equity and tax benefits pay off long-term, even with PMI for lower down payments.
- Rent if: Short-term stay (under 3 years), low savings, or high-cost city (e.g., SF, where $150K barely covers rent). Flexibility trumps ownership costs.
For $100K-$200K single earners, renting is smarter now if rates drop further (expected 50 basis points by year-end). Buying makes sense in stable markets with at least 10% down.
In 2025’s housing market, the Fed cut helps, but affordability depends on your situation. Weigh flexibility vs. equity, and always consult a financial advisor rather than making an emotional decision.
For more information see:
